Otisco Lake - Fish Catch Report

Report Catch
Fish Caught
7
  • Best Months to Fish:
    AprilAugust
  • Best Time to Fish:
    Noon: 12 to 3pm
    Evening: 6 to 9pm
  • Ideal Temperature to Fish:
    Cold: 45 to 55°F
  • Popular Catch:
    Tiger Muskellunge, Largemouth Bass and Walleye

Fishing report for Otisco Lake, New York. Most popular fish caught in Otisco Lake are Tiger Muskellunge, Largemouth Bass and Walleye. The 7 fish that anglers reported catching are listed here and include description, weight and size of the fish and date caught. If you fish on Otisco Lake please report your catch here to let other anglers know what fish are available.

Tiger Muskellunge
Caught: August 9, 2020
Tiger Muskellunge
Caught: January 5, 2020
Tiger Muskellunge
Caught: August 3, 2017
Walleye
Caught: April 30, 2017
Tiger Muskellunge
Caught: September 22, 2016
Largemouth Bass
Caught: April 26, 2015
Largemouth Bass
Caught: April 26, 2015